We have all heard countless sermons preached on the story of the Prodigal Son. Focusing on topics from the son’s rebellious and disregard for his father’s authority, to a selfish and immature attitude, to his drastically sinful nature and life.
The older brother doesn’t get talked about too often. Yet, when we do hear about him, we are presented with a picture of jealously, and told how we need to avoid it, and rejoice when a ‘sinner’ returns to God.
Yet, there are some key points to this story that have stood out to me recently, that I have rarely ever heard discussed.
One is how both sons misinterpreted, or didn’t trust their father’s heart. This is crucial to understand.
Was the young son’s perception that his father was, or would, hold out on him? That he wasn’t getting all he wanted or deserved? We’re not clearly told in the story what the son was thinking, yet, you can conclude that he misinterpreted his father’s heart.
What about the older son?
He stayed home, even though he received his share of the estate the same time his brother did! Where was his heart, his perception about his father? He makes it pretty clear for us, “…worked like a slave for you, and I never disobeyed your commands.” I’m willing to say he totally misinterpreted his father’s heart.
As soon as the younger son asks for “his share of the estate that will belong to him”, the father freely gives it, to both sons. There is no dialog in the story about his father pleading with him to not take it, begging him not to waste it, or telling him what he can and can’t do with it. He doesn’t tell him that he is going to have to wait like everyone else. He simply gives it to him, unconditionally.
Think about that.
And his response to the older son on the return of the younger, “Son, you are always with me, and everything that belongs to me is yours.”
Did you hear that?!
What’s the father’s heart in this story? He gives unconditionally, holding nothing back, to both sons!
Do you understand that all God has is yours?
There are plenty of other stories in the bible about misinterpreting or not trusting God’s heart.
When the Israelis first arrived at the door of the promised land, what happened? They didn’t trust God’s heart and it landed them in the desert.
Adam and Eve? … They didn’t trust God’s heart.
How have you misinterpreted the Father’s heart? Are you the younger son, thinking God is holding out on you? The older son, thinking you have to earn or work for God’s favor?
Do you Trust Him?
(You can!)
Tweet






#1 by Gloria on March 16, 2010 - 3:26 am
Quote
I actually have to remind myself more often that the older brother had a lesson to learn, too. I has been a long time since I've desired to run away, but it's all too easy to stay home and tsk, tsk what that young twerp is doing out thee.
#2 by Rocco Capra on March 16, 2010 - 11:47 am
Quote
It's easy to be the older brother, the 'Pharisee', when we don't understand God has given us everything, that we don't have to work for it!
#3 by bill (cycleguy) on March 19, 2010 - 7:22 pm
Quote
Hey Rocca! Had you in my google reader and wondered why I hadn't seen any new posts. Now I do. Will change my reader. Just finished reading Prodigal God by Tim Keller and his premise about the elder son is the whole Pharisee thing. I have blogged about just this weekend. http://billgrandi.ovcf.org/wordpress/?p=3551 Hope you will take a look. I was a legalist for far too many years and never ever want to go back there. Never! BTW: did I say never? And the amazing part of the Luke 1 parable is exactly what you said: the father gave his love to both sons. Will be back.
#4 by bill (cycleguy) on March 19, 2010 - 7:22 pm
Quote
Sorry Rocco. Hit wrong key. :)
#5 by Rocco Capra on March 19, 2010 - 7:55 pm
Quote
No problem, I've been called worse!
Thanks for stopping by and sharing your blog. Great point about the Pharisitical(sp) Older Brother, I didn't want to touch that one, maybe some other day ;)
#6 by Bill (cycleguy) on March 20, 2010 - 11:56 am
Quote
That should read Luke 15 parable. Man, my fingers had dyslexia and forgetfulness.
#7 by Dave Taylor on March 22, 2010 - 1:25 pm
Quote
So many want to analyze every part of this story. We want a nice system of beliefs we can manage, we are all naturally pharasaical at heart and can miss the "heart" in the story. What is the heart of the message? What is the heart of each charachter in the story – which heart draws you? Which heart repels you? The Fathers heart is repelling to the older son and drawing to the younger. I want to be drawn to God's heart…not repelled by His great grace.
#8 by Rocco Capra on March 22, 2010 - 1:54 pm
Quote
His Heart is Good.
#9 by Matt_TCoNP on March 26, 2010 - 2:57 am
Quote
Rocco, thanks for your comment on my blog. I actually just preached this passage last Sunday. It was really cool. My take was that the older and younger bros motivations were the same – they just took different paths to try to get there. They didn't love Dad for Dad. Little bro tried to get around Dad to get the estate (and all the happiness and control over his life that came with it – self discovery.) Big bro tried to be good…to get the estate (and everything else.)
It made me realize, Jesus was talking to Pharisees when he told this story. He was comparing them to the older brother. And I have a lot more in common with the Pharisees that with the outcasts.
#10 by Rocco Capra on March 31, 2010 - 12:50 am
Quote
Hey Matt,
Yeah, I think those of us who have been Christians for a number of years will relate more to the older brother/Pharisees.
And I am still loving the "everything that belongs to me is yours." – Wow.
#11 by Mason Stanley on May 19, 2010 - 1:29 am
Quote
Man, this was a great thought provoking post! What amazes me, which this post made me think about, is that both sons were worried about the "stuff!" And you see the father's attitude about the stuff is as if it doesn't matter at all. He is more worried about the relationships being reconciled and the family being put back together. I guess after all…it's just "stuff."
#12 by Rocco Capra on May 19, 2010 - 2:23 am
Quote
Oh yeah, Mason!